Saturday, May 04, 2013

Relegation Day (Again!)

 
"Let's get rid of McCarthy and lets start climbing that table"

Those words were written on a Wolves message board - on Facebook actually - in January last year. Sixteen months and three managers later, Wolves have been relegated twice in succession and will be playing in the third tier of English football next season. Be careful what you wish for...

Anyone who has followed this blog will know that I was gutted when Wolves sacked Mick McCarthy. Despite the mauling by West Bromwich Albion that preceded his departure I still felt he remained our best hope of avoiding the drop and our best chance of coming straight back should we be relegated. I've said my piece about that in previous posts here and here so I'm not going to go over old ground.

However, I'm going to quote something that I posted back in February last year:

"Mick's "putting in a shift" quote has almost become a joke, except that it isn't really because before Mick McCarthy arrived you couldn't really guarantee that all Wolves players would actually give 100% effort every week. Mick McCarthy instilled that.... I do worry for us now. I've seen this before when Wolves sacked Dave Jones. The board pressed the panic button and got rid of a decent manager on a bad run, only to replace him with someone who took the club no further forward and actually undid some of the good work that had gone before. I hope the board don't live to regret making the decision they have taken this week."

And my God don't we just!? At least under Glen Hoddle all we were faced with was passionless, gutless, mediocre football, rather than the complete unravelling of everything the club had worked towards since the summer of 2006 as is the case now. 

When Wolves sacked Mick McCarthy the board stated that they wanted to replace him with a manager with proven Premier League experience. To then appoint someone with no managerial experience at all in Terry Connor beggars belief. The subsequent appointment of Stale Solbakken, a man with a very  different footballing philosophy to McCarthy and who had never managed in England before was described at the time as "thinking outside the box" but it was also at the very least a gamble. This wasn't so much a case of building and improving on what had gone before as ripping up the foundations and starting all over again. 

Five months in, with the team starting to flounder, Wolves abandoned the "culture change" following a 1-0 FA Cup defeat at non league Luton Town. Within 48 hours we had installed former Doncaster Rovers boss Dean Saunders as our new coach. I like Dean Saunders; he's a positive, affable guy and was a very good player in his day, but there was nothing on his CV to suggest that he would be a success at Championship level. He'd finished mid table twice with non league Wrexham before guiding them to a play-off semi final (which they lost to Luton Town) and then moved to Doncaster Rovers where he was leading a strong push for promotion to the Championship, having been relegated with them the season before. Once again, another gamble...

The reason I started this blog post with that quote is that there still seems to be a "scapegoat mentality" at Wolverhampton Wanderers - a belief that if only we could get rid of Mick McCarthy/Terry Connor/Stale Solbakken/Dean Saunders/Jez Moxey/Steve Morgan/These Players (insert names of whoever you like here) then everything would be OK and right order would be restored. I'm afraid it's not that simple anymore.

So much of what Wolves are - or rather were - was built around Mick McCarthy's philosophy. As a side we were disciplined, hard working and organised.  We played 4-4-2 (or 4-5-1 if we were being defensive). We put in a shift, marked man to man and had wingers that tracked back. With the parachute money all gone and our better players off to pastures new the team was built around older, experienced players (Gary Breen, Jody Craddock, Chris Iwelumo) and "young and hungry" bargain buys from the lower leagues keen to make a name for themselves (Michael Kightly, Andy Keough, Matt Jarvis, Sylvan Ebanks-Blake etc.) Yes, it had its limitations but it was enough to get us promoted as Champions and keep us in the Premier League, if only just!

These days I really couldn't tell you what our style of play is. We've tried 5-4-1, 3-5-2 and 4-4-1-1. We've played with wing backs. We've changed from playing with width and gettting it out wide to playing possession football, sometimes with no wingers. We've played with a high line to catch teams offside, we've tried defending deep and tried marking zonally. Lately we seem to be just making it up as we go along.

This year has also seen an influx of loan signings mainly brought in by Dean Saunders and international players from France, Iceland, Togo, Mali, Poland, Slovakia and Austria mainly brought in by Stale Solbakken. Some of these signings have worked relatively well (e.g. Siguroarson, Sako) and others less so but only very rarely has this disparate group of individuals ever looked like a team.

The team spirit, the "band of brothers" mentality that was once so integral to Wolves is in bits. In its place is a group of players with different styles and varying levels of commitment, ability or willingness to play for the club, or in a certain way, or for a particular manager. Add to that mix certain Wolves players who need to take a long, hard look at themselves during the close season and others that quite clearly have long since given up giving 100% and you have a squad that needs grabbing by the scruff of the neck and shaking. It won't be a quick fix - any more than it was under Mick McCarthy - but without it anyone who thinks Wolves are getting out of League One in the right direction any time soon are kidding themselves.

The starting point of our current shambles though has to be laid at the feet of club owner Steve Morgan. It was his decision to sack Mick McCarthy. It was his decision not to appoint a safe, available but probably unpopular successor (Steve Bruce - whatever happened to him!) and instead gamble on someone who had no managerial experience at any level (Terry Connor). It was his decision to take Wolves in a different direction with the appointment of a foreign coach (Stale Solbakken) and then to abandon that to appoint a manager whose only experience of Championship football was eight months at Doncaster Rovers which ended in relegation (Dean Saunders). It's not simply a matter of successive appointments not working out in the way we'd hoped - each appointment has been risky to begin with. I do not question Steve Morgan's commitment to Wolverhampton Wanderers but I would seriously question his decision making when it comes to football matters.

We increasingly appear to be a club without a plan. We have a stated desire to be back in the Premier League but seemingly no idea how we're actually going to achieve this. Even suggesting that we want to be a Premier League club sounds laughable right now. We no longer seem to know what sort of club we want to be, how we want our team to play or who to employ as manager to make this a reality.

I have no complaints about Wolves being relegated. We haven't been in the least bit unlucky this season and we deserve to go down. For me, I will be there next season. I love my club. I've supported them in all four divisions and this relegation changes nothing.

My hope is that Steve Morgan talks to the fans. My hope is that players who couldn't bring themselves to give 100% for my club are long gone by the time next season comes around. Please leave - and close the door behind you.

There is much work to do during the summer and Wolves will be a very different club next season. Frankly, we have to be...