On 3rd August 2018 - just over 35 years since it was originally released - Electric Light Orchestra's 'Secret Messages' is finally released as a double album as originally conceived. Well, sort of...
To understand the story of the album you have to go back to
the Autumn of 1982, when Jeff Lynne entered Wisseloord studio in Hilversum with
Richard Tandy, Bev Bevan and Kelly Groucutt to record (at least) five new
songs: 'Loser Gone Wild', 'No Way Out' (featuring Kelly on double bass) 'Train
Of Gold', 'Motor Factory' and 'Beatles Forever'. With only two releases
remaining under his contract with Jet Records, Jeff Lynne intended creating a
double album as ELO’s last studio project.
It was at this point that a couple of unanticipated events occurred. The first was that Kelly Groucutt, who had contractually been a salaried employee of the band since joining in 1974, decided to pursue legal
action against Jeff Lynne and ELO's management on the grounds that he had contributed significantly
to the ELO sound and consequently deserved a fairer wage. The matter was
settled out of court (reportedly for £300.000) and Kelly was dismissed as a session
musician, although he did later return for two promotional videos and various
promotional photographs.
With ELO now down a trio of Tandy/Lynne/Bevan they were occasionally augmented by recent touring member Dave Morgan, Louis Clarke returned to arrange strings on selected tracks (the strings on the previous album, Time, had been arranged by Rainer Pietsch) whilst long-serving member Mik Kaminski made a cameo appearance on ‘Motor Factory’ playing a heavily-processed violin solo fed through the AMS RMX 16 digital effects rack that Jeff was using extensively at this point.
With Jeff Lynne experimenting with samplers, reverb devices and drum machines, drummer Bev Bevan increasingly provided percussion or rototom accompaniment. He did however get to cut loose on the excellent 'Danger Ahead', the brilliant but chilling depiction of nuclear apocalypse of 'Time After Time' (which featured Jeff's then-wife Sandi on backing vocals) and the closing section of an epic track entitled 'Hello My Old Friend' - of which more anon.
ELO's rockier side was represented by 'Four Little Diamonds', (the spoken 'Kelly's not on' reference in the introduction was a knowing reference to the fact that Kelly wasn't on: the track featured only Jeff Lynne and Dave Morgan), whilst the industrial sounds of 'Motor Factory' were softened and the lyrics rewritten (twice) to become 'Rock N Roll Is King'. Other tracks featured only Jeff Lynne, such as the brooding 'Mandalay' or the sadly reflective 'Letter From Spain'.
However, the album's magnum opus, the concluding statement of the Electric Light Orchestra both musically and chronologically was the proposed album closer, 'Hello My Old Friend'. It's an affectionate portrait of the Birmingham Jeff Lynne grew up in along with local references (Spatch and Mail!') that goes dreaming off into an ambient mid section with echoing keyboards, sound effects and field recordings of children singing 'Frere Jacques' before returning for a Beatlesque ending with a descending guitar riff that references '10538 Overture', an orchestral motif directly borrowed from 'The Diary Of Horace Wimp' and looped tape effects. It was the perfect conclusion for a band whose vision was to pick up where the Beatles had left off with 'Strawberry Fields Forever' and 'I Am The Walrus'.
In March 1983 Jeff Lynne headed to Los Angeles to compile the album. He returned with three discs, the first two featuring a sequence for the double album and a third disc of alternate takes, single versions and out-takes. Jet Records assigned a catalogue number of Jet DP402 for the following album:
Side One: Secret Messages; Loser Gone Wild: Bluebird: Take Me On & On.
Side Two: Stranger; No Way Out; Beatles Forever; Letter From Spain; Danger Ahead
Side Three: Four Little Diamonds; Train Of Gold; Endless Lies; Buildings Have Eyes; Rock N Roll Is King
Side Four: Mandalay; Time After Time; After All; Hello My Old Friend.
And then...
....And then the second unexpected event occurred. Jet Records, lamely citing the oil crisis and global recession, rejected the idea of a double album, the proposed track listing, and indeed the original artwork (pictured above). The revised artwork became a combination of a picture by HAG entitled The Future's A Bit Fishy. We've Got A Hand In It further embellished by Wherefore Art.
All of the original Side One was kept intact with six of the remaining fourteen songs crammed onto Side Two. The ending to 'Hello My Old Friend' was recycled onto the end of 'Rock N Roll Is King', which allowed the album to retain some of its conceptual unity.
In the years that followed some of the tracks slowly trickled out of the vaults:
Time After Time - was a bonus track on the 12" single of 'Rock N Roll Is King' as well as a bonus track on the 1983 cassette & CD versions of the album.
After All - Was the flip side to 'Rock N Roll Is King', although the released version was 2 mins 23 seconds rather the the version on the original Secret Messages which was only a 41 second interlude and remains unreleased.
Buildings Have Eyes - Was the flip side to 'Secret Messages' single and later appeared on the Afterglow box set.
Mandalay, No Way Out and an edited version of Hello My Old Friend all appeared on the deleted Afterglow box set. Worth noting too was that the introduction to 'Four Little Diamonds' on the box set version was slightly longer.
Endless Lies - Appeared on the 2001 CD reissue of Secret Messages. Worth noting here is that there is an error at the end of this edition of the album as it uses the dead end' version of 'Rock N Roll Is King' (that would have appeared at the end of the original Side Three) rather than the ending transferred from 'Hello My Old Friend' as per the original single album edition.
Beatles Forever - Unreleased, though a few poor quality Mp3 copies circulate.
The released album was not without controversy. Accused by (frankly, bonkers) right wing Christian groups of including secret backward messages on their albums that were Satanic in nature, Jeff Lynne went to town with this and placed utterly innocuous messages within and between songs and even on the album sleeve to satirise just how ridiculous these claims were. The released album was a source of frustration for Jeff however, not only artistically in that he had to edit an 18 track double album down to just 10 songs due to record company politics, but also because a single disc edition of Secret Messages meant that Jeff was still bound to his contract to produce a further ELO album...
Which leads us to this release. Despite being marketed as presenting the album 'As originally conceived' the track listing does NOT include 'Beatles Forever'. Whatever the merits of the song - and opinion is divided on the issue - its omission is both a disappointment and a massive missed opportunity and renders the statement that this is the album Jeff 'originally conceived' as a falsehood. My only hope is that the album will show attention detail in other ways and reconstruct the album as it was meant to be, including the 41 second version of 'After All' (as Jeff planned it) rather then the longer version which can easily be pulled off the shelf. Crucially I hope it will also restore the album coda to the end of 'Hello My Old Friend' as it was originally envisaged.
Secret Messages was a magnificent album -the last truly great ELO album for me - but in its original 18 track double album form it was a classic. This release, frustratingly, may not be all that it could be, but it's the closest to the complete version that we've ever had. It deserves to be presented properly and with care after all this time...and I haven't given up hoping for 'Beatles Forever' as a hidden bonus track as part of the digital download. I can still dream.
It's been a long time coming. 'Welcome To The Show...'
With ELO now down a trio of Tandy/Lynne/Bevan they were occasionally augmented by recent touring member Dave Morgan, Louis Clarke returned to arrange strings on selected tracks (the strings on the previous album, Time, had been arranged by Rainer Pietsch) whilst long-serving member Mik Kaminski made a cameo appearance on ‘Motor Factory’ playing a heavily-processed violin solo fed through the AMS RMX 16 digital effects rack that Jeff was using extensively at this point.
With Jeff Lynne experimenting with samplers, reverb devices and drum machines, drummer Bev Bevan increasingly provided percussion or rototom accompaniment. He did however get to cut loose on the excellent 'Danger Ahead', the brilliant but chilling depiction of nuclear apocalypse of 'Time After Time' (which featured Jeff's then-wife Sandi on backing vocals) and the closing section of an epic track entitled 'Hello My Old Friend' - of which more anon.
ELO's rockier side was represented by 'Four Little Diamonds', (the spoken 'Kelly's not on' reference in the introduction was a knowing reference to the fact that Kelly wasn't on: the track featured only Jeff Lynne and Dave Morgan), whilst the industrial sounds of 'Motor Factory' were softened and the lyrics rewritten (twice) to become 'Rock N Roll Is King'. Other tracks featured only Jeff Lynne, such as the brooding 'Mandalay' or the sadly reflective 'Letter From Spain'.
However, the album's magnum opus, the concluding statement of the Electric Light Orchestra both musically and chronologically was the proposed album closer, 'Hello My Old Friend'. It's an affectionate portrait of the Birmingham Jeff Lynne grew up in along with local references (Spatch and Mail!') that goes dreaming off into an ambient mid section with echoing keyboards, sound effects and field recordings of children singing 'Frere Jacques' before returning for a Beatlesque ending with a descending guitar riff that references '10538 Overture', an orchestral motif directly borrowed from 'The Diary Of Horace Wimp' and looped tape effects. It was the perfect conclusion for a band whose vision was to pick up where the Beatles had left off with 'Strawberry Fields Forever' and 'I Am The Walrus'.
In March 1983 Jeff Lynne headed to Los Angeles to compile the album. He returned with three discs, the first two featuring a sequence for the double album and a third disc of alternate takes, single versions and out-takes. Jet Records assigned a catalogue number of Jet DP402 for the following album:
Side One: Secret Messages; Loser Gone Wild: Bluebird: Take Me On & On.
Side Two: Stranger; No Way Out; Beatles Forever; Letter From Spain; Danger Ahead
Side Three: Four Little Diamonds; Train Of Gold; Endless Lies; Buildings Have Eyes; Rock N Roll Is King
Side Four: Mandalay; Time After Time; After All; Hello My Old Friend.
And then...
....And then the second unexpected event occurred. Jet Records, lamely citing the oil crisis and global recession, rejected the idea of a double album, the proposed track listing, and indeed the original artwork (pictured above). The revised artwork became a combination of a picture by HAG entitled The Future's A Bit Fishy. We've Got A Hand In It further embellished by Wherefore Art.
All of the original Side One was kept intact with six of the remaining fourteen songs crammed onto Side Two. The ending to 'Hello My Old Friend' was recycled onto the end of 'Rock N Roll Is King', which allowed the album to retain some of its conceptual unity.
In the years that followed some of the tracks slowly trickled out of the vaults:
Time After Time - was a bonus track on the 12" single of 'Rock N Roll Is King' as well as a bonus track on the 1983 cassette & CD versions of the album.
After All - Was the flip side to 'Rock N Roll Is King', although the released version was 2 mins 23 seconds rather the the version on the original Secret Messages which was only a 41 second interlude and remains unreleased.
Buildings Have Eyes - Was the flip side to 'Secret Messages' single and later appeared on the Afterglow box set.
Mandalay, No Way Out and an edited version of Hello My Old Friend all appeared on the deleted Afterglow box set. Worth noting too was that the introduction to 'Four Little Diamonds' on the box set version was slightly longer.
Endless Lies - Appeared on the 2001 CD reissue of Secret Messages. Worth noting here is that there is an error at the end of this edition of the album as it uses the dead end' version of 'Rock N Roll Is King' (that would have appeared at the end of the original Side Three) rather than the ending transferred from 'Hello My Old Friend' as per the original single album edition.
Beatles Forever - Unreleased, though a few poor quality Mp3 copies circulate.
The released album was not without controversy. Accused by (frankly, bonkers) right wing Christian groups of including secret backward messages on their albums that were Satanic in nature, Jeff Lynne went to town with this and placed utterly innocuous messages within and between songs and even on the album sleeve to satirise just how ridiculous these claims were. The released album was a source of frustration for Jeff however, not only artistically in that he had to edit an 18 track double album down to just 10 songs due to record company politics, but also because a single disc edition of Secret Messages meant that Jeff was still bound to his contract to produce a further ELO album...
Which leads us to this release. Despite being marketed as presenting the album 'As originally conceived' the track listing does NOT include 'Beatles Forever'. Whatever the merits of the song - and opinion is divided on the issue - its omission is both a disappointment and a massive missed opportunity and renders the statement that this is the album Jeff 'originally conceived' as a falsehood. My only hope is that the album will show attention detail in other ways and reconstruct the album as it was meant to be, including the 41 second version of 'After All' (as Jeff planned it) rather then the longer version which can easily be pulled off the shelf. Crucially I hope it will also restore the album coda to the end of 'Hello My Old Friend' as it was originally envisaged.
Secret Messages was a magnificent album -the last truly great ELO album for me - but in its original 18 track double album form it was a classic. This release, frustratingly, may not be all that it could be, but it's the closest to the complete version that we've ever had. It deserves to be presented properly and with care after all this time...and I haven't given up hoping for 'Beatles Forever' as a hidden bonus track as part of the digital download. I can still dream.
It's been a long time coming. 'Welcome To The Show...'

































